LegalLegal ruling has implications for farming inheritance rows

Legal ruling has implications for farming inheritance rows

A LANDMARK legal ruling could have far reaching implications in disputes over the future of family farms.

Rebecca Armstrong, a Contentious Trust and Probate Specialist with Cartmell Shepherd Solicitors, said the judgment by the Supreme Court on Wednesday (October 19) would impact farming families who find themselves in legal battles over who will inherit the farm.

Rebecca said: “The ruling was unusual in that it offered the parties a choice as to how the case could be resolved, with remedies deemed fair and equitable to both parties. 

“These high profile cases are a reminder that people need to be clear about their plans for the future. Leaving the future of your farm unresolved can lead to animosity and upset between family members, which can cause years of legal battles and, in some cases, the sale of the farm.

“The principle of proprietary estoppel within the farming community is essentially a parent promising a son or daughter that: ‘One day, all this will be yours.’ It’s a promise or assurance to another person that they have or will be given an interest in property which that other person then relies upon to their detriment.

“In farming families, that can mean the son or daughter working long hours for low rates of pay for many years on the promise that they will inherit the farm after their parents’ death. If, as in this case, that doesn’t happen, then it can lead to legal fights over what they believe is their rightful inheritance.”

The case heard by the Supreme Court was brought by a son (Andrew) against his parents (David and Josephine), who own the farm. In Partnership with his parents, Andrew had lived and worked on the farm for 32 years since leaving school, earning a basic wage and living in a property on the farm.

Andrew had been promised by his parents that he would inherit a substantial but unspecified share of the farm, along with his two siblings.

Following a deterioration in the family relationship, David and Josephine changed their wills, disinheriting Andrew. The farming partnership was ultimately dissolved and Andrew forced to leave the farm property where he and his family lived.

Andrew took the case to court where the judge awarded him a lump sum based on his expected inheritance; however, his parents argued that it should have been calculated on his contribution to the value of the farm or his loss of opportunity to work elsewhere. They said the sum should be based on what he had expected to receive on his parents’ death.

The Supreme Court ruled that the farm should either be put in trust for the three children to inherit after their parents’ death as originally promised or that Andrew is given a lump sum which reflects the fact he has received his inheritance before his parents’ death.

Rebecca, who is an Associate Solicitor with Cartmell Shepherd’s Contentious Probate team, said: “Each case is dependent on its specific facts, but this ruling does set a precedent in respect of the flexibility the Courts have when determining matters. It ensures that Andrew’s expectations are met but not exceeded and provides the parties with options which could avoid the potential sale of the farm.”

Cartmell Shepherd operates across Cumbria, Northumberland and nationally and has six offices at Rosehill Carlisle, Carlisle city centre, Brampton, Penrith, Cockermouth and Haltwhistle, with the firm’s full range of legal services available from all of its offices, delivered by a team of more than 40 solicitors.

Contact Rebecca on 01228 516666 or email [email protected]

News Desk
News Deskhttps://www.businessmanchester.co.uk/
The Business Manchester News Desk team is a collective of experienced journalists and editors dedicated to delivering comprehensive business news and insights from the Manchester area and beyond. With a strong background in finance, technology, property, and innovation, our team ensures that our readers stay well-informed about the latest trends and developments in the business world. Through in-depth reports and insightful analysis, the Business Manchester News Desk team is committed to providing high-quality journalism to its audience.
Latest

73% of Manchester Garage Roof Enquiries Mention Asbestos

New analysis of 921 local enquiries reveals asbestos concerns, garage dimensions and roofing patterns across Manchester's M postcode area. Nearly three in four garage roof...

Briars Group wins three international Stevie Awards, including CEO Gold for global leadership

Andrew Fahey recognised for cross-cultural leadership as Briars also secures two Silver awards for international collaboration and expansion. Briars Group has won three awards at...

UK’s first baby loss support app launches dedicated area for families facing termination for medical reasons

Ellie’s Gift, the UK’s first baby loss support app, has launched a dedicated area for parents going through a termination for medical reasons (TFMR). The...

Premium European specialities offer retailers new opportunities across the 2026 festive season

Retailers could find new opportunities this Christmas by tapping into consumers’ appetite for premium European food, informal entertaining and more varied festive gifting. Experts...
Subscribe to our newsletter
Business Manchester will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you and to provide updates and marketing.
Don't miss

73% of Manchester Garage Roof Enquiries Mention Asbestos

New analysis of 921 local enquiries reveals asbestos concerns, garage dimensions and roofing patterns across Manchester's M postcode area. Nearly three in four garage roof...

 Christmas toy appeal calls on borough residents to help families in need

Rochdale Borough Council’s staff-run charity 'Number One Riverside Giving Back' is now collecting donations for this year’s Christmas Toy Appeal, which helps make sure...

Tyres.co.uk Gets Behind Cardiff Racing’s Electric Formula Student Car

Tyres.co.uk, the UK online tyre retailer, is joining forces with Cardiff Racing to help the Cardiff University students prepare their electric race car for...

5 Best SEO and GEO agencies in Manchester

When a customer searches for a supplier, compares products or looks for a local service, they might start with Google, ask ChatGPT for a...

More News

Bolton family law firm expands service to Warrington

VM Family Law is extending its face-to-face appointments beyond Bolton, giving clients in Warrington and the surrounding area the option to meet their lawyer...

Why Expert Legal Support Matters in Commercial Property Transactions

Commercial property plays an important role in business growth, whether a company is opening its first office, expanding into larger premises, or investing in...

Record Cat Welfare Petition Puts Road Collision Reporting Laws Under Parliamentary Scrutiny

STOURBRIDGE, UK. October 8th, 2026 – A landmark campaign led by feline welfare organisation CatsMatter is set to bring renewed attention to the legal...