BusinessAlbright IP Wins Landmark High Court Case for Liking Ltd

Albright IP Wins Landmark High Court Case for Liking Ltd

In a significant Intellectual Property Enterprise Court ruling, Albright IP has achieved a major legal victory for its client, Liking Ltd, in a copyright dispute brought by WaterRower (UK) Ltd.

The judgment has established a crucial precedent for the copyright protection of functional 3D objects, clarifying the definition of “a work of artistic craftsmanship” under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 (CDPA).

WaterRower argued that their water-resistance rowing machines were works of artistic craftsmanship, protected by copyright. They alleged that Liking Ltd’s Topiom rowing machines had infringed this copyright by replicating substantial elements of the design.

In response, Liking Ltd maintained that the WaterRower machines did not meet the criteria for works of artistic craftsmanship and, therefore, could not qualify for copyright protection.

Judge Campbell Forsyth, delivering his decision, ruled that WaterRower machines, including their prototype, fail to meet the legal requirements to be classified as works of artistic craftsmanship. As a result, the machines do not benefit from copyright protection under UK law.

This judgment highlights a notable divergence between UK and EU approaches to copyright law, bringing greater clarity to the standards required for 3D functional objects to gain copyright eligibility in the UK.

Commenting on the case, Cloe Loo, Patent Director at Albright IP, said: “This judgment provides much-needed clarity in UK copyright law on what qualifies as a work of artistic craftsmanship. For a number of years, conflicting UK and EU case law has created uncertainty around copyright protection for 3D objects that aren’t sculptures. This ruling establishes that such objects must meet the test of artistic craftsmanship to qualify for copyright. It’s an important milestone for the IP sector.”

Loo detailed the complexities of the case, which involved overcoming language barriers and time zone challenges to communicate effectively with her client.

“Working closely with Liking Ltd required not only a robust IP strategy but also a deep understanding of their language and business culture. Communicating the nuances of UK copyright law in Chinese, for instance, was essential to ensure our client was fully informed and comfortable with each stage of the case,” she explained.

Albright IP’s Managing Director, Robert Games, praised Loo’s efforts, stating: “We are immensely proud of Cloe. This was a challenging, multilingual case which was set to impact IP law. Cloe’s ability to build her team and manage these complexities in both English and Chinese is a testament to her commitment and expertise. This outcome is a notable achievement for Albright IP and highlights our team’s strength in high-stakes IP litigation.”

This decision has significant implications for the intellectual property sector, particularly in shaping copyright law for functional 3D objects. Whether an appeal will follow remains to be seen, but the judgment represents a key development in defining artistic craftsmanship in the context of UK copyright law.

Link to judgement in full: https://www.albright-ip.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/WaterRower-v-Liking-2024-EWHC-2806-IPEC-Approved-Judgment-11-November-2024.pdf

News Desk
News Deskhttps://www.businessmanchester.co.uk/
The Business Manchester News Desk team is a collective of experienced journalists and editors dedicated to delivering comprehensive business news and insights from the Manchester area and beyond. With a strong background in finance, technology, property, and innovation, our team ensures that our readers stay well-informed about the latest trends and developments in the business world. Through in-depth reports and insightful analysis, the Business Manchester News Desk team is committed to providing high-quality journalism to its audience.
Latest

Terence Ang Takes AI-Narrated Poetry to NCTE 2026 Following International Award Wins

Singaporean author living with aphasia will showcase award-winning audiobook Brokenness Becomes Beautiful in Philadelphia, bringing disability inclusion, technology and creative expression into focus. A Singaporean...

Former HCA Healthcare technology chief joins SciSure Board

Life sciences software provider SciSure has strengthened its Board of Directors with the appointment of Marty Paslick, who brings more than three decades of...

WellBox launches milestone gifting platform for employers

WellBox, the B Corp certified corporate gifting company, has launched milestone gifting, a platform that helps employers mark work anniversaries, birthdays and other career...

Avensure Reaches 15-Year Milestone as Client Base Exceeds 7,000 Businesses

The Manchester-founded HR, employment law and health & safety company celebrates nationwide growth, strong review scores and further investment in its services and technology. Avensure...
Subscribe to our newsletter
Business Manchester will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you and to provide updates and marketing.
Don't miss

WellBox launches milestone gifting platform for employers

WellBox, the B Corp certified corporate gifting company, has launched milestone gifting, a platform that helps employers mark work anniversaries, birthdays and other career...

Best Christmas gifts for women 2026: Our festive gift guide

Christmas shopping can be great fun, but finding the right gifts for all the women in your life isn't always quite so easy. Whether...

Terence Ang Takes AI-Narrated Poetry to NCTE 2026 Following International Award Wins

Singaporean author living with aphasia will showcase award-winning audiobook Brokenness Becomes Beautiful in Philadelphia, bringing disability inclusion, technology and creative expression into focus. A Singaporean...

Women Account for Just One-Third of Finance Conference Speakers, New Research Reveals

Pomona Partners calls on event organisers to improve gender representation across finance conference programmes New research from Pomona Partners has revealed a significant gender imbalance...

More News

Terence Ang Takes AI-Narrated Poetry to NCTE 2026 Following International Award Wins

Singaporean author living with aphasia will showcase award-winning audiobook Brokenness Becomes Beautiful in Philadelphia, bringing disability inclusion, technology and creative expression into focus. A Singaporean...

WellBox launches milestone gifting platform for employers

WellBox, the B Corp certified corporate gifting company, has launched milestone gifting, a platform that helps employers mark work anniversaries, birthdays and other career...

Five business owners share their predictions for the 2027 business landscape

While nobody can predict exactly what the next twelve months will bring for businesses, experienced business owners can draw on their knowledge, insights, and...