FootballMan City 1-1 Real Madrid (4-4 agg, 3-4 pens): Holders suffer penalty...

Man City 1-1 Real Madrid (4-4 agg, 3-4 pens): Holders suffer penalty heartache

Real Madrid ended Manchester City’s hopes of back-to-back trebles with a dramatic penalty shoot-out win in the Champions League quarter-finals, with Bernardo Silva and Mateo Kovacic both failing to convert from the spot.

Pep Guardiola’s side dominated for long periods after Rodrygo – who memorably scored twice against City in the 2022 semi-finals – gave Madrid an early lead, and Kevin De Bruyne’s equaliser took them to extra time.

However, City were unable to force a winner and ultimately suffered penalty heartache, with Andriy Lunin keeping out dreadful kicks from Silva and Kovacic to swing it Madrid’s way after Ederson denied Luka Modric.

Read our other sports news stories here:
IPL 2024: Punjab Kings v Mumbai Indians – preview, free bets and offers
Will Kobbie Mainoo Force His Way Into England’s Euro 2024 Plans?
Archer targets T20 World Cup in home island of Barbados

Ederson stepped up to convert a must-score penalty for City, but Antonio Rudiger held his nerve to slot home the decisive kick, avenging Madrid’s 4-0 defeat at the Etihad Stadium in last year’s semi-finals.

Carlo Ancelotti’s men will now face Bayern Munich for a place in June’s final at Wembley Stadium, with English interest in the competition over after the Bundesliga giants beat Arsenal 3-2 on aggregate.

City dominated possession early on, but Madrid went ahead from their first real attack. Kyle Walker played Vinicius Junior onside as he escaped down the right to cross for Rodrygo, and though the Brazilian’s first attempt was kept out by Ederson, he made no mistake with the rebound.

That goal spurred the hosts into action, and they went agonisingly close to a swift equaliser when Erling Haaland headed against the crossbar and the loose ball bounced wide off Silva.

City continued to push but were twice denied by Lunin either side of half-time, Madrid’s stand-in goalkeeper pushing De Bruyne’s fierce drive to safety then parrying Jack Grealish’s volley.

The visitors were forced deeper and deeper as City made it a game of attack-versus-defence, and their pressure finally told with 76 minutes played. Rudiger made a mess of clearing Jeremy Doku’s low cross, and De Bruyne was on hand to hammer into the roof of the net from close range.

De Bruyne should have completed the turnaround five minutes later, but he blazed over after being found by Manuel Akanji’s cutback in a miss that would later prove costly.

Both Haaland and Vinicius were withdrawn shortly after the end of the 90 as the pattern of the game remained set in stone, but Madrid should have gone ahead in the 105th minute when Rudiger somehow prodded over the crossbar from close range.

That was the final clear-cut chance as two tiring teams went to penalties. Things looked to be going City’s way when Ederson pushed Modric’s kick away, but Silva and Kovacic both failed to beat Lunin – the former chipping a terrible penalty straight into his hands.

Ederson slotted City’s fifth attempt home to keep them in it, but Rudiger made up for his extra-time miss with the all-important kick, rolling his effort into the bottom-left corner to dump the champions out.

Harry Carr
Harry Carr
Harry is a freelance sports journalist with experience of working for the Racing Post, Stats Perform, Opta Analyst and more, covering major events across all sports but holding a particular love for the beautiful game.
Latest

As AI Creates More Content, Human Curation May Become the New Digital Filter

With artificial intelligence making it easier to produce and distribute digital content at unprecedented scale, web entrepreneur Miles Noble believes trusted human judgement could...

Engage Customer Summit returns to London on 7 and 8 October

The two-day edition brings 3,000 senior leaders and case studies from 250 of the world’s largest brands to Evolution London, built around a joined-up...

Rising demand for pawnbroking drives 115% profit increase for Prestige

LONDON, UK. September 23rd, 2026: Growing numbers of Britons are using valuable possessions to unlock cash, with Prestige Pawnbrokers reporting a major rise in...

Asbestos Continues to Claim Thousands of Lives Each Year, Says Shield Services Group

BRISTOL, UK. September 23rd, 2026 - The long-term impact of asbestos exposure remains a significant concern for businesses, landlords and property owners, with thousands...
Subscribe to our newsletter
Business Manchester will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you and to provide updates and marketing.
Don't miss

Asbestos Continues to Claim Thousands of Lives Each Year, Says Shield Services Group

BRISTOL, UK. September 23rd, 2026 - The long-term impact of asbestos exposure remains a significant concern for businesses, landlords and property owners, with thousands...

Orchids are officially Britain’s most baffling houseplant, a year of search data shows

DEVON, UK. September 21st, 2026 - No plant confuses Britain like the orchid. Devon nursery Houseplant.co.uk analysed a year of Google search data and...

Vernon Building Society invites charities and businesses to save with a purpose

Vernon Building Society is inviting charities and businesses to place their surplus funds with a local mutual that combines a reliable, fixed return with a...

Autumn maintenance spotlight falls on the gutters Derby homeowners cannot see

With autumn approaching, a routine property maintenance task deserves a place alongside heating checks and garden clearance: finding out whether rainwater can actually leave...

More News

Manchester United going ‘in good direction’, Ten Hag says despite results

Manchester United's results show the club is going "in a good direction", manager Erik ten Hag has said despite his side's thrashing by Liverpool...

bet365 becomes official global partner of UEFA Champions League

bet365, one of the world’s leading online betting companies, has announced a historic sponsorship agreement, becoming the first official sports betting partner of the...

Manchester United: Getafe hope to keep Greenwood

Getafe president Angel Torres is confident Mason Greenwood will return to the Spanish club on loan next season if Manchester United can’t sell him...