NewsBDB Pitmans and Manchester Ship Canal win historic Supreme Court decision

BDB Pitmans and Manchester Ship Canal win historic Supreme Court decision

Private property owners can now take legal action against water companies which dump raw sewage into canals, rivers and other bodies of water in England and Wales.

The Supreme Court ruled in The Manchester Ship Canal Company Ltd v United Utilities Water Ltd (No 2) that the law does not prevent the Manchester Ship Canal from making claims for damages over unauthorised discharges of waste.

BDB Pitmans, the law firm that represented Manchester Ship Canal, said the decision potentially opens the doors to substantial claims against sewerage undertakers for water pollution.

The decision is the latest turn in a long-running battle between the Manchester Ship Canal, owned by the Peel Group, and United Utilities.

The Manchester Ship Canal, built in the 1890s, extends 36 miles from the Mersey Estuary to Salford Quays and includes over 100 outfalls along the length of the canal through which United Utilities releases effluent from its wastewater network.

Whilst most of that effluent is treated, the Supreme Court heard that raw sewage is dumped into the canal when the network is operating over capacity. The Supreme Court judges said this could be avoided if the company “invested in improved infrastructure and treatment”.

The unanimous Supreme Court decision, which overturns decisions in the High Court and Court of Appeal, entitles the Manchester Ship Canal to bring a nuisance or trespass claim for unauthorised sewage discharges even where there had been “no negligence or deliberate misconduct”.

The court made clear that water companies will not be permitted to leave watercourse owners to bear the clean-up costs of unauthorised sewerage discharges, stating that “a successful claim for damages for incidents of pollution of a watercourse will impose costs on a sewerage undertaker; but the effect is merely to prevent it from externalising the costs of its operations by leaving them to be borne by the victims of its unlawful behaviour”.

Richard Langley, senior partner, BDB Pitmans representing the Manchester Ship Canal, said: “The judgment has significant consequences for the water industry and those affected by unauthorised sewerage discharges. Any watercourse owner will now have a right to bring claims in common law nuisance in respect of pollution to their water, whether directly or upstream, and to seek injunctions to restrain polluting activity by any sewerage undertaker and/or damages for the unlawful interference with the watercourse.”

A United Utilities spokesperson said: “We are considering the implications of the Supreme Court’s ruling and the clarification of the circumstances in which private owners could bring proceedings in respect of discharges.

“We understand and share people’s concerns about the need for change and we have already made an early start on an ambitious proposed £3 billion programme to improve over 400 storm overflows across the North West which would cut spills by 60% over the decade to 2030. These proposals form part of our business plan which is currently under consideration as part of Ofwat’s price review process.”

Helen Greaney
Helen Greaney
I'm a journalist with more than 18 years' experience on local, regional and national newspapers, as well as PR and digital marketing. Crime and the courts is my specialist area but I'm also keen to hear your stories concerning Manchester and the greater North West region.
Latest

Terence Ang Takes AI-Narrated Poetry to NCTE 2026 Following International Award Wins

Singaporean author living with aphasia will showcase award-winning audiobook Brokenness Becomes Beautiful in Philadelphia, bringing disability inclusion, technology and creative expression into focus. A Singaporean...

Former HCA Healthcare technology chief joins SciSure Board

Life sciences software provider SciSure has strengthened its Board of Directors with the appointment of Marty Paslick, who brings more than three decades of...

WellBox launches milestone gifting platform for employers

WellBox, the B Corp certified corporate gifting company, has launched milestone gifting, a platform that helps employers mark work anniversaries, birthdays and other career...

Avensure Reaches 15-Year Milestone as Client Base Exceeds 7,000 Businesses

The Manchester-founded HR, employment law and health & safety company celebrates nationwide growth, strong review scores and further investment in its services and technology. Avensure...
Subscribe to our newsletter
Business Manchester will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you and to provide updates and marketing.
Don't miss

Former HCA Healthcare technology chief joins SciSure Board

Life sciences software provider SciSure has strengthened its Board of Directors with the appointment of Marty Paslick, who brings more than three decades of...

Salary transparency puts employer culture and leadership under the spotlight

Pay is becoming a more open part of the recruitment process across Europe, but employers may find that publishing salary information is only the...

Best Christmas gifts for women 2026: Our festive gift guide

Christmas shopping can be great fun, but finding the right gifts for all the women in your life isn't always quite so easy. Whether...

Women Account for Just One-Third of Finance Conference Speakers, New Research Reveals

Pomona Partners calls on event organisers to improve gender representation across finance conference programmes New research from Pomona Partners has revealed a significant gender imbalance...

More News

First cold snap of winter to put boilers under increased pressure across North West

The first cold snap of the winter, which is due to hit North West England this week, is expected to lead to a surge...

 Christmas toy appeal calls on borough residents to help families in need

Rochdale Borough Council’s staff-run charity 'Number One Riverside Giving Back' is now collecting donations for this year’s Christmas Toy Appeal, which helps make sure...

Manchester Christmas Markets are open with more than 200 stalls to browse

The countdown is on... Manchester's Christmas Markets are officially open! With more than 200 stalls in ten different locations across the city centre, the markets...