18.2 C
Manchester
Monday, July 7, 2025
Football'The ultimate luxury player' – Jamie Carragher says Erling Haaland is not...

‘The ultimate luxury player’ – Jamie Carragher says Erling Haaland is not world-class

Erling Haaland has been described as “the ultimate luxury footballer” by Jamie Carragher, with the former defender insisting the Manchester City star is not a world-class player.

Haaland scored 52 goals in all competitions as City won the treble last season and has 30 to his name in 2023-24, but that has not stopped him becoming the subject of fierce criticism lately.

Following a quiet performance from the Norwegian in a drab goalless draw between City and Arsenal two weeks ago, Roy Keane said Haaland’s all-round game was akin to that of a League Two player.

Read our other Erling Haaland news stories here:
Keane doubles down on Haaland ‘League Two player’ jibe
Man City: Former Real Madrid star Van der Vaart hits out at ‘useless’ Haaland
Manchester City boss Pep Guardiola says Haaland can improve areas of his game

Keane doubled down on those comments this week, saying the striker’s general play is “nowhere near good enough” on a weekly basis.

While City boss Pep Guardiola acknowledged Haaland can still improve on Friday, he also said there was “no chance” his team would have won last season’s Premier League, Champions League and FA Cup trophies without him.

Former Liverpool defender Carragher, though, has echoed Keane’s sentiments, saying Haaland is not yet on the level of Premier League greats Thierry Henry, Luis Suarez and Harry Kane.

In a column for The Telegraph, Carragher wrote: “Erling Haaland is the ultimate luxury footballer.

“He is undoubtedly one of the worlds greatest goalscorers but is yet to become a world-class player. To be truly world-class you need more than one, all-encompassing trait.

“Think of the best Premier League strikers of the last 20 years – Thierry Henry, Luis Suarez or Harry Kane – and they had or have a major influence on the biggest matches whether they scored or not.

“All of them could play for any side in the world and contribute more than an impressive strike rate.

“In general play, Haaland is not at the same level as these strikers yet, his three most recent games against top-class centre-backs confirming that for all his brilliance inside the penalty area, he is a work-in-progress out of it.

“Virgil van Dijk, William Saliba and Antonio Rudiger bullied Haaland, the much-hyped showdowns between top defenders and a goal machine were nothing of the sort. They were a mismatch rather than a match-up.”

Harry Carr
Harry Carr
Harry is a freelance sports journalist with experience of working for the Racing Post, Stats Perform, Opta Analyst and more, covering major events across all sports but holding a particular love for the beautiful game.
Latest

Hillbrush Debuts Tornado Broom Range for Tough Outdoor Cleaning Environments

Hillbrush has launched its innovative Hillbrush Tornado Range — a robust, modular broom system designed to raise the bar for strength, reliability, and outdoor...

Blaugranagram Partners with 101 Great Goals to Deliver Deeper Fan-Focused Football Content

101 Great Goals has officially entered into a strategic content partnership with Blaugranagram, aiming to enrich the football experience for fans by combining their...

Left Behind by the Algorithm: AI Benefits Bosses, But Workers Struggle to Keep Up

• Senior managers are far more likely to use AI than junior staff, new study finds • 73% of leaders use AI each month, compared...

Craig Cornick Cleared of Hacking Charge in Long-Running ICO Case

A Manchester businessman has been found not guilty of computer hacking, following a lengthy investigation and prosecution brought by the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO). Craig...
Subscribe to our newsletter
Business Manchester will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you and to provide updates and marketing.
Don't miss

Left Behind by the Algorithm: AI Benefits Bosses, But Workers Struggle to Keep Up

• Senior managers are far more likely to use AI than junior staff, new study finds • 73% of leaders use AI each month, compared...

Craig Cornick Cleared of Hacking Charge in Long-Running ICO Case

A Manchester businessman has been found not guilty of computer hacking, following a lengthy investigation and prosecution brought by the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO). Craig...

Blaugranagram Partners with 101 Great Goals to Deliver Deeper Fan-Focused Football Content

101 Great Goals has officially entered into a strategic content partnership with Blaugranagram, aiming to enrich the football experience for fans by combining their...

Hillbrush Debuts Tornado Broom Range for Tough Outdoor Cleaning Environments

Hillbrush has launched its innovative Hillbrush Tornado Range — a robust, modular broom system designed to raise the bar for strength, reliability, and outdoor...

More News

Manchester United going ‘in good direction’, Ten Hag says despite results

Manchester United's results show the club is going "in a good direction", manager Erik ten Hag has said despite his side's thrashing by Liverpool...

bet365 becomes official global partner of UEFA Champions League

bet365, one of the world’s leading online betting companies, has announced a historic sponsorship agreement, becoming the first official sports betting partner of the...

Manchester United: Getafe hope to keep Greenwood

Getafe president Angel Torres is confident Mason Greenwood will return to the Spanish club on loan next season if Manchester United can’t sell him...